Everyone sits in a circle. One person is “it”. He or she must walk over to someone and say, “Honey, if you love me you will smile.” They can make faces or noises, etc., but no touching or tickling.
If the targeted person laughs then they must be “it”. If they don’t laugh they must say to the “it” person, “Honey, I love you but I just can’t smile.” Then “it” must find another person to make them laugh.